Coconut (N)Ice!

It was that time of the week when the need for a little sweetness kicked in (hard!), and with dad away it didn’t seem quite right to make the caramel popcorn that has shot to the top of his list of favourites. (He remembers eating it as Crackerjacks in his early childhood many years ago and is just loving having it around again.) But, with the jar of Almond Brittle now looking like thisGEDSC DIGITAL CAMERA

not making anything was not an option. After getting caught up watching a sweet romantic comedy (to offset a morning of good hard rugby), it needed to be quick and easy and using ingredients we definitely had in the kitchen, preferably not too many. After mum and I paged through a whole lot of recipe books and torn out magazine pages, I decided it would be coconut ice – and I specifically wanted to make the more traditional version, without condensed milk.

Mom popped up with a recipe from the Your Family Magazine of July 1988 at about the same time I found one on Nigella’s website, which had the same ingredient list but in different quantities. The given techniques were a bit different, and I combined a bit of each in my attempt, and it all seemed to work out really well. So, here is my coconut ice recipe and method. It took 47 minutes to make, and 2.5 hours to set.

Makes +/- 40 pieces


720g sugar

150ml water????????????????????

150ml milk (I used fat free, because it’s what we drink)

150g dessicated coconut

A few drops of pink food colouring (emphasis on “a few” – man, this stuff is intense!)


20×20 cm baking tin

Non-stick spray

Wooden spoon

Large pot (You’ll see on the pictures that this mixture boils “up”. My 3l pot was just big enough to ensure “up” didn’t become “over”.)

Butter knife (for spreading in the tin)

Cutting board

Sharp knife


  1. Spray the baking tin with non-stick spray and set aside.
  2. Place the sugar, water and milk in the pot and heat on low heat  (number 2) on the stove, stirring gently until all the sugar has dissolved and it starts to boil – about 12-15 minutes. With the milk, it is difficult to see when the sugar is dissolved. The gentle stirring helps to determine whether there is any undissolved sugar left. You can also scoop a little out (like I did) to check what’s on the spoon.GEDSC DIGITAL CAMERA????????????????????????????????????????
  3. When the mixture starts to boil, stop stirring. Leave the boiling mixture to cook for 13 minutes without stirring. It will bubble and froth, rising up quite high in the pot (see the 3rd photo below). It doesn’t thicken. (Nigella says heat till it thickens, but it really doesn’t.) At 13 minutes, my candy thermometer was just under 120C (the recipes don’t use a thermometer, only time, so I thought I’d check).????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
  4. After 13 minutes, take the pot off the heat and add the coconut.GEDSC DIGITAL CAMERA
  5. Beat the mixture quite vigorously with the wooden spoon for about 5 minutes, until it thickens. Note that it’s not very thick when ready, it just doesn’t drip off the spoon easily.GEDSC DIGITAL CAMERA
  6. Pour half the mixture into the prepared tin and spread out evenly.GEDSC DIGITAL CAMERA
  7. Add about 3-5 drops of pink food colouring to the remaining mixture in the pot and stir through quickly. Again, I emphasise the 3-5 drops for a light pink ice. I put in just about half a lidfull  (is that a word?) of a small bottle of colouring and it still came out darker than I really wanted. Not a real problem, but still.????????????????????GEDSC DIGITAL CAMERA
  8. Pour the pink ice on top of the white in the baking tin, and spread evenly.????????????????????????????????????????
  9. Leave to set until cold. (I left mine for 2.5 hours – while I updated the blog – and it was fine.)
  10. When cold, turn out. (This will be easy if you sprayed the tin sufficiently, it just slides out.) Interestingly, it didn’t look quite as bright pink anymore, but is still a little pinker than planned (shop versions are really pale).????????????????????
  11. Using a sharp knife, cut into 5 bars about 4cm wide. Cut each bar into pieces, as wide as is your preference. It’s pretty sweet (and sweetly pretty!) so I cut mine about 2.5cm wide. (Not that accurately though, which is how I ended up with a rather odd number of pieces – 45.)????????????????????GEDSC DIGITAL CAMERA
  12. Voila! Coconut ice – really nice, really sweet, really simple.????????????????????
  13. Store in an airtight container (or wrap individually in cellophone paper, if you have time and a good reason to. I didn’t.)

4 responses to “Coconut (N)Ice!

  1. Pingback: Coconut (N)ice(r) | Sweeti Pi·

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s